In your opinion, what objective would a/the perfect game have?

more than one, having multiple makes a game not only last longer but also makes it more fun.

Interesting, I always loved task-based games.

yes, if well made, they can be very fun

Fishing could be a good side quest for my game... [will add]

I'd think one that most people wouldn't expect, or that hasn't been used a lot in other works. Perhaps one where the player doesn't know what the character (he's playing as) is searching for, or wants to obtain, but you slowly get clues throughout the game as to what he wants. That's the storyline I'd put into an exploring game like that. (Also, I really like that awesome treasure chest) :)

Thx, I have a lot of experience in drawing loot chests, and this is a partial show-off of my 'meh' spriting. Love that suggestion, btw.