UndertaleSB update PetitModem isn't working so I am ordering a thing to plug in to my n3ds so it will work. One good thing is I got Frisk all splinked.
You are aware that you can't remake Undertale without getting a cease & desist, right? Undertale is copyrighted and will be taken down if published in SB. Smartest thing to do is to stop working on it, or at least to keep it as a personal project.
Just letting you know.
I don't think so. Toby has been very generous on behalf of other people to let them work on fan projects, like Undertale Yellow. As long as they're getting no profit from it, it should be pretty cool.
What worries me is memory and musuc issues, but you guys should know how to fix that...
There's a difference between a fan game and a straight-up remake. Fan games are OK since they usually offer a different experience than the original game. Remakes can harm the developer because it can offer the experience of the original game through means other than official releases.
So most likely he was talking about fan games, not remakes.
@Oscar There have been many remakes of games in SB. The only copyrighted one was fnaf sb because he gave no credit and scott cawthan is strict about fan games
Actually, there have NOT been many remakes on SB. Those few that exist have been of either abandonware or games that are open-source/copyleft/that openly allow for such things as remakes.
Undertale does NOT fall under any of these.
FNAF SB ran into these problems and is a prime example as to why people should avoid recreating copyrighted content.
"As long as they're getting no profit from it, it should be pretty cool."
SmileBOOM IS making profit from anything you submit, since people have to buy SmileBASIC to access the server.
Example: « oh heyy fnaf is on the 3ds!!!!!1 gota buy smilebasic evryone!!! »
And that's how SmileBOOM makes money on something they don't own.
That is a lie because many people in this community only buy it to play other's creations. They have no intention of creating their own programs.
So you can't say that.
If I make one change he can't sue me because I made it my own. Have you ever looked up full episodes of tv on youtube and nodiced they are slightly speed up? That's how they don't get sued
Just because they can't get copyright claimed doesn't mean they aren't doing anything wrong.
Want someone to like your game? Then make it original.
There is nothing original about a game that's even based off of another.
Sequels from the original creator are actually legal, though.
Also, don't try to twist the law around to your convenience. That's how villains are born.
Look up OpenHexagon. It's a clone that's been up for quite some time now. Terry Cavanagh has expressed no issue with clones, and he was credited properly in it.
Also, all I'm is saying that you shouldn't be misinterpreting the law, because that can lead to more problems.
Remaking a copyrighted game to be a carbon copy without permission is against the law. It is something a bootlegger would do.
I'm getting tired of receiving notifications from a kid who tries to find reasons to have copyrighted games on SB
Just don't do it, okay? That's not what SB was made for.
Still, you must understand it is not something you can do just because you want to. If you want to play Undertale, it will have to be through legal methods, that is to say, buy it and play it on PC. That is the way Toby Fox intended, and it's the way you must accept.
Recreating the demo is also prohibited. Just because it is shorter doesn't make it any less copyrighted than the full game.
Using copyrighted characters for a fan game could also be problematic, but maybe doable.
Okay, let me elaborate my reasonings. First, Toby Fox has the authority, not you.
Second, FanART is different than FanGAMES.
Third. It is up to Toby Fox to create Undertale for the 3DS.
Fourth. W. D. Gaster is even licensed by Toby Fox, even though you had to hack the game to find him.
No one knows if that man in that grey room is Gaster though. So if he puts some random doodle toby made on MS Paint that has almost nothing to do with the game its fine.
Just make the game with another plot twist and add W.D Gaster and put all the credits saying that all sprites and stuff are Toby Foxes creations. It's not that bad to remake it, you just have to be sure that nothing is exactly the same.
